I’ve always been a sort of “denial” girl. If it’s bad news? I don’t really wanna hear it. I told Long Board not long ago that I don’t often want the ugly truth, but am very content with the pretty lie. Not on the big things – but with the little things? Absolutely!
So “honesty” doesn’t seem as black and white to me as it does to some people.
Now I realize this next part is going to sound absolutely nutball coming from a girl that hid her pregnancy, never told friends or family, and is now in a secret open adoption! However, when it comes to adoption – my instinct is to say that honesty is the best policy no matter what! (Which I realize means I’m breaking my own policy).
And sometimes I believe that…..but I’m the first to admit that I am susceptible to falling into that dark world of denial. That world where the pretty lie is better than the ugly truth. And I don’t think that I’m the only one.
I do think that there are some truth’s however that need to be upheld no matter what.
I believe that a child has absolute rights to know that he/she is adopted, and to have access to as much of his/her biological familial history, medical information, etc. No questions asked. That’s their truth and they should know it. If their parents (aparents, bparents, whatever letter you wanna put in front of ‘parents’ – whomever it is) are scared to tell the child the truth? I think that’s something that they need to work out. It’s not fair to the child.
So – with such a strong stance on that particular bit of truth, how can I find the rest a little hazy? How can I sit here day after day babbling about my fears of telling Long Board about Cupcake?
Because it’s different.
Cupcake is my daughter. My daughter that never asked to be adopted. My daughter that will always be my daughter no matter what. Her adoption impacts her directly. It’s a part of her story. Keeping that from her is a lie by omission – but I think it’s also more than that. It’s a constant deception about who she is.
Long Board is my boyfriend. He never asked to date a woman with a daughter (that I know of) but he did choose to date me. When he chose to date me, there was a lot that he didn’t know about me, and a lot that I didn’t know about him. There’s a lot we still don’t know about each other…but that’s the point of dating, right? To learn those things. Long Board will not always be my boyfriend no matter what. Now I’m not forecasting a breakup at this point – but let’s be realistic. Of all the relationships one has in their life, very few of them end up being the long-term-love-of-your-life-picket-fence-golden-anniversary-die-in-each-others-arms deals. I’m not saying LB is or isn’t this, but that I certainly don’t know yet! We’ve known each other for three months and thirteen days. And we’ve been dating ever since. Yes, I am keeping something from him. I am lying by omission…..but I think all dating is at some point lying by omission….right?
How many of us go on a first date and lay all of our cards on the table?
There’s lots I haven’t told LB….I haven’t told him about the guy I lost my virginity to. I haven’t told him about the fight my Mom and I had that changed our relationship forever. I haven’t told him about the abusive boyfriend I had. I haven’t told him how many guys I’ve slept with. I haven’t told him about the things I’m most afraid of or the things that I want most in the world.
And I haven’t told him about Cupcake.
All of these might be things he’d want to know about – and we’ll get there with most of them, but in due time.
It’s easy to point to Cupcake and say, “But that’s HUGE. How can you not tell him about that???”
And I don’t know what my answer is except to say that I’m not ready.
But that I’m putting more work into being ready for this than I’ve put into any emotional thing in a really long time – maybe ever.

I would never pose that three months into a romantic relationship you have an obligation to tell the other person something that you haven’t told your family. I think you are smart to be doing the work towards telling LB about Cupcake, but just wanted you to know from one of your devoted readers, I’m not sitting here reading this thinking “I cannot believe she is keeping this from him!”
Quite the contrary, I’m thinking “whoa she must like this guy to be even considering telling him already.” ♥
By: Alissa on October 15, 2009
at 2:07 pm
Alissa – in many ways it’s your last sentence that scares me the most! haha
but thank you for these words
By: thanksgivingmom on October 15, 2009
at 2:27 pm
Maybe I should have phrased it “whoa, this must be pretty real, for her to be considering telling him already.”
I think it’s valid to want him to know. ♥
By: Alissa on October 15, 2009
at 2:32 pm
Either way – I think you’re on the money. I like the kid a lot (happy everyone? I’m admitting it! haha) and this feels eerily real.
It’s funny, I went out for drinks with a buddy (who’s in a pretty real relationship with a girl for the first time in a LONG time) and we both looked at each other and went, “Holy crap – we’re in relationships!”
I’m definitely still in the part where it surprises me sometimes. But it’s a pleasant surprise
By: thanksgivingmom on October 15, 2009
at 2:59 pm
I think you should consider telling him sooner than later, before you are more involved. Telling someone about my son was paramount to my having a relationship with them. For me it was better to get it on the table and see exactly where the relationship stood, or could go.
Yes, I lost a lot of opportunities but in reality what were those opportunites? I was a mother to a child afterall. I have been in a 20+ marriage with a wonderful guy. The others were losers.
By: angelle2 on October 15, 2009
at 7:29 pm
I like your analogy – it works, and it’s totally true. I think any relationship must grow over time and as you reach different levels of comfort with the person, LB in this case, you share more and more of who you are.
When you reach that stage of your relationship that you want LB to know about Cupcake, it’ll come naturally. Until then, it’s an important part of who you are but an extremely private one too. And that fact means it’s not just for anyone to know about and rather something you will only share with a person who plays a big enough part in your life that they deserve to know.
By: Barely Sane on October 15, 2009
at 10:07 pm
I think the time will come soon enough when you are ready. And only you will know when that time will be. It’s not like you are saying “hey guess what, I’m wearing blue socks today”. It’s something that could change everything. I think in your last post you did a pretty good explaining your reasoning why you are waiting. And first and formost you need to be emotionally ready for this. Like you said, it’s only been 3 months. And seriously, how many IRL friends actually know about cupcake? Not a whole lot. So that fact that you are not only letting an IRL “friend”, but a boyfriend in on your secret is HUGE.
*Amy*
By: Amie on October 15, 2009
at 10:47 pm
Only you will know when the right time to share is.
All I’m going to do is gently remind you of one thing – the longer you wait, the harder it gets. Trust me on this.
I’m thinking of you.
By: Coco on October 16, 2009
at 9:51 am
*I* think you are going to use this as a test. you know, you always try to be the first one to break things off, you always seem to be the one running away. 6 months into a relationship is pretty long time to keep someone as important as your daughter!
I did the same thing. When I would get semi-serious I would throw the “I’m a mom card”. I think you are always going to find it being a “bad time” or not the “perfect time”
IMHO
By: jessica on October 16, 2009
at 1:16 pm
I meant to respond to this earlier and it slipped my mind…..I think I’m not telling him right now because I don’t want it to be something that I use to push him away. In the past, yes, I can admit that I thought this would push guys away and I could use that to my advantage. Now, I’m TERRIFIED of it having the effect that I used to expect it to have. Which actually feels very strange to me…..
By: thanksgivingmom on October 19, 2009
at 3:31 pm
OK, I’m just catching up in blogland, so I did not know you were talking about telling LB! Oh my!
For the record, I told other boys before. Not many, but I did drop the bomb here and there. Sometimes it was a test. Other times it was to explain why it didn’t bother me that my barback ex boyfriend (Jerky) was in the same room as us. I gathered it was TMI for most of them. Them again, it’s TMI for most people, I’m coming to realize
My hubby did not find out for over nine months. And I never stressed about it before hand. I told him after being contacted out of the blue by Jerky about contacting M. I knew there was NO WAY I could carry on a dialogue with him behind hubby’s back, and there was no way I would withhold info from Jerky about our daughter. Had that not happened, I’m not sure when I would have told him. I was a little worried he’s wonder why I waited so long to tell him. But I knew it was safe.
You’ll know when it’s safe too. Tell him in your own time
By: brown325 on October 21, 2009
at 6:07 pm
Wow! Guess I haven’t kept you in the loop very well huh?? (You need to be able to email at work again!!!! haha)
We can take this offline (to email) but do you think you would have told him earlier if you had been in contact with AM at that point? Or if you were in an OA?
By: thanksgivingmom on October 22, 2009
at 8:23 am